Chapter 18. A Typical Calculation

Table of Contents

Input File (optimization/opt_gnorm.dat):
Archive File (optimization/opt_gnorm.arc):
Ouput File (optimization/opt_gnorm.out):

The following is an example illustrates the features that are found in a typical calcuation. The most important features are noted below, which is helpful for new users to identify critical data sections. This example involves a geometry optimization and background information on optimization can be found in the section called “Geometry Optimization”

Input File (optimization/opt_gnorm.dat):

  am1 rhf singlet gnorm=0.05 t=auto truste grad geo-ok  1
Distorted Benzene
GNORM
 C              0.000000  0    0.000000  0    0.000000  0    0    0    0
 C              1.500000  1    0.000000  0    0.000000  0    1    0    0
 C              1.200000  1  110.000000  1    0.000000  0    2    1    0
 C              1.500000  1  130.000000  1   20.000000  1    3    2    1
 C              1.200000  1  105.000000  1  -20.000000  1    4    3    2
 C              1.500000  1  130.000000  1   25.000000  1    5    4    3
 H              0.800000  1  109.500000  1  145.000000  1    1    2    3
 H              1.200000  1  130.000000  1 -135.000000  1    2    3    4
 H              1.200000  1  109.500000  1  140.000000  1    3    4    5
 H              0.800000  1  130.000000  1 -135.000000  1    4    5    6
 H              1.200000  1  120.000000  1 -135.000000  1    5    6    1
 H              0.800000  1  120.000000  1  145.000000  1    6    1    2
 0              0.000000  0    0.000000  0    0.000000  0    0    0    0   2
	

1

The keyword line specifies that the AM1 Hamiltonian will be used. Specifying GNORM=0.05 tightens the criterion for optimizing the geometry. The geometry provided is very distorted, so GEO-OK is needed to allow the calculation to proceed.

2

The geometry specification section is terminated by a line of zeros. A blank line would also serve this purpose. No further data is required by the keywords, so this is the last line of the file.

Archive File (optimization/opt_gnorm.arc):

 Timestamp:  2011-08-31-12-47-10-00000010A4-win64
 User Info:  John Millam, Nahum, 

                     SUMMARY OF AM1 CALCULATION    1
                                                       Aug-31-2011
                          AMPAC Version 10.0.1    2
                             Presented by:
  
                        Semichem, Inc.
                        www.semichem.com
  
 FORMULA: C6H6    3
 Distorted Benzene
 GNORM

     GEOMETRY OPTIMIZED : ENERGY MINIMIZED
     SCF FIELD WAS ACHIEVED
 
          FINAL HEAT OF FORMATION   =        22.022286 kcal    4
                                    =        92.163265 kJ
          ELECTRONIC ENERGY         =     -3253.371822 eV
          CORE-CORE REPULSION       =      2403.035502 eV
          TOTAL ENERGY              =      -850.336320 eV
          GRADIENT NORM             =         0.110345     5
          RMS GRADIENT NORM         =         0.020146     6
          UNSTABLE MODE(S)          =         0 ( ESTIMATE  )    7
          IONIZATION POTENTIAL      =         9.652544 eV    8
          HOMO-LUMO GAP             =        10.207126 eV
          DIPOLE                    =         0.000349 debyes    9
          MOLECULAR WEIGHT          =        78.113400    10
          MOLECULAR POINT GROUP     = D6h     0.100000    11
          NO. OF FILLED LEVELS      =        15 (OCC = 2)    12
          TOTAL NUMBER OF ORBITALS  =        30
          COMPUTATION TIME          =         0.27     SECONDS    13

          FINAL GEOMETRY OBTAINED    14                            CHARGE    15
 AM1 RHF SINGLET GNORM=0.05 T=AUTO TRUSTE GRAD GEO-OK    16
 Distorted Benzene
 GNORM
  C     0.000000  0    0.000000  0    0.000000  0      0     0     0   -0.1301    17
  C     1.395028  1    0.000000  0    0.000000  0      1     0     0   -0.1301
  C     1.395067  1  120.000213  1    0.000000  0      2     1     0   -0.1301
  C     1.395020  1  120.000241  1   -0.006540  1      3     2     1   -0.1301
  C     1.395082  1  119.998278  1    0.001454  1      4     3     2   -0.1301
  C     1.395027  1  120.001057  1    0.000382  1      5     4     3   -0.1301
  H     1.099676  1  119.998309  1  180.004635  1      1     2     3    0.1301
  H     1.099643  1  119.999025  1 -180.008087  1      2     3     4    0.1301
  H     1.099652  1  120.001668  1  179.989239  1      3     4     5    0.1301
  H     1.099696  1  119.999758  1 -179.996667  1      4     5     6    0.1301
  H     1.099636  1  119.998960  1 -180.006599  1      5     6     1    0.1301
  H     1.099604  1  120.000057  1  179.987363  1      6     1     2    0.1301
  0     0.000000  0    0.000000  0    0.000000  0      0     0     0
	

1

The banner indicates which Hamiltonian (here AM1) was used to obtain the results.

2

This line gives information about which version of AMPAC (in this case 10.0) was used in this calculation. This data must be referenced when publishing results.

3

The molecular formula of the species is printed.

4

The Heat of Formation (ΔHf) begins the summary section in the .arc file. This value is computed from the ELECTRONIC ENERGY and the CORE-CORE REPULSION ENERGY. See the section called “Semiempirical Heats of Formation” for details.

5

The gradient norm (gnorm) value indicates how well the geometry has been refined. A value of less than 1.0 is acceptable for most purposes. See discussion of the GNORM=n.n keyword for additional information. (See Chapter 4, Computational Procedures for an explanation of how gnorm is computed.)

6

The RMS gradient norm (RMS gnorm) is another indicator of how well the geometry has been refined. It is similar to the regular gnorm but is scaled so as to be approximately independent of the system size. (See Chapter 4, Computational Procedures for an explanation of how the RMS gnorm is computed.)

7

The number of unstable modes is useful for classifying the optimized geometry. The number of modes is qualified with the statement ESTIMATED indicating that number of unstable modes may not in fact be correct. To get an accurate number for the unstable modes, do a FORCE (or LFORCE or HESSEI) calculation on the optimized geometry or optimize the geometry with a full Hessian method (NEWTON or LTRD). (See Chapter 4, Computational Procedures for an explanation on how to characterize stationary points.)

8

The ionization potential (as predicted by Koopman’s Theorem as the negative of the energy of the HOMO) is listed in electron volts (eV).

9

The dipole moment (in Debyes) is reported. As expected with benzene, this value is essentially zero.

10

The molecular weight as calculated from the molecular formula is given. Note that the atomic masses used in AMPAC are the isotopically averaged ones found on the Periodic Table of the Elements.

11

The molecule’s molecular point group is listed here. The number following the symmetry designation is the threshold used for determining the point group. This threshold can be changed by using the MPGCRT keyword.

12

For even electron systems, the number of doubly-occupied valence shell orbitals is noted in the summary section. Other information is presented if the calculation involved an open shell species or configuration interaction.

13

The total time for the calculation is listed here. If extensive post-SCF calculations are performed, see the bottom of the .out file for a more exact estimate of the CPU time actually used. This time will vary widely depending on the speed of the system used to do the calculation.

14

This phrase is presented at the end of most successful AMPAC runs where the calculation has been completed as requested.

15

A summary of the Coulson atomic charges as predicted by AMPAC’s analysis of the MOs is listed in the archive file.

16

The keyword line and comments are echoed back to allow the user to identify the results and interpret the calculation.

17

The final optimized geometry as predicted by the program is listed in internal coordinates in the order that the atoms were entered. If the geometry was in initially provided in internal coordinates, the connectivity remains the same as defined. If the geometry was provided as Cartesian coordinates, AMPAC will assign a connectivity pattern.

Ouput File (optimization/opt_gnorm.out):

 Timestamp: 2011-08-31-12-47-10-00000010A4-win64
 User Info: John Millam, Nahum, 
 *******************************************************************************
                         AM1 CALCULATION RESULTS    1
 *******************************************************************************
 *                             AMPAC Version 10.0.1    2
 *                                Presented by:
 *
 *                           Semichem, Inc.
 *                           www.semichem.com
 *
 *  AM1      - THE AM1 HAMILTONIAN TO BE USED    3
 *  RHF      - RESTRICTED HARTREE-FOCK CALCULATION
 *  TRUSTE   - MINIMIZE ENERGY USING TRUST REGION METHOD
 *  GNORM=   - OPTIMIZATION EXIT WHEN GRADIENT NORM BELOW    0.050
 *  GEO-OK   - OVERRIDE INTERATOMIC DISTANCE CHECK
 *  T=AUTO   - AUTOMATIC DETERMINATION OF ALLOWED TIME
 *  GRADIENTS- ALL GRADIENTS TO BE PRINTED
 *  SINGLET  - IS THE REQUIRED SPIN MULTIPLICITY
 *******************************************************************************
 AM1 RHF SINGLET GNORM=0.05 T=AUTO TRUSTE GRAD GEO-OK    4
 Distorted Benzene
 GNORM
    ATOM    CHEMICAL   BOND LENGTH    BOND ANGLE    TWIST ANGLE    5
   NUMBER   SYMBOL     (ANGSTROMS)     (DEGREES)     (DEGREES)
    (I)                   NA:I          NB:NA:I      NC:NB:NA:I     NA    NB    NC
      1     C 
      2     C          1.50000 *                                     1
      3     C          1.20000 *      110.00000 *                    2     1
      4     C          1.50000 *      130.00000 *    20.00000 *      3     2     1
      5     C          1.20000 *      105.00000 *   -20.00000 *      4     3     2
      6     C          1.50000 *      130.00000 *    25.00000 *      5     4     3
      7     H          0.80000 *      109.50000 *   145.00000 *      1     2     3
      8     H          1.20000 *      130.00000 *  -135.00000 *      2     3     4
      9     H          1.20000 *      109.50000 *   140.00000 *      3     4     5
     10     H          0.80000 *      130.00000 *  -135.00000 *      4     5     6
     11     H          1.20000 *      120.00000 *  -135.00000 *      5     6     1
     12     H          0.80000 *      120.00000 *   145.00000 *      6     1     2

   MOLECULAR POINT GROUP            SYMMETRY CRITERIA
            C1                          0.10000000    6

          SINGLET STATE CALCULATION    7

          RHF CALCULATION, NO. OF DOUBLY OCCUPIED LEVELS =      15

        **  REFERENCES TO PARAMETERS  **

 H  (AM1):  M.J.S. DEWAR ET AL, J. AM. CHEM. SOC. 107 3902-3909 (1985).    8
 C  (AM1):  M.J.S. DEWAR ET AL, J. AM. CHEM. SOC. 107 3902-3909 (1985).

          CARTESIAN COORDINATES    9
      ATOM            X               Y               Z
       1 C        0.00000000      0.00000000      0.00000000
       2 C        1.50000000      0.00000000      0.00000000
       3 C        1.91042417      1.12763114      0.00000000
       4 C        1.22554224      2.40296821      0.39300395
       5 C        0.05271549      2.15436289      0.34130475
       6 C       -0.66121710      0.84150901      0.47059108
       7 H       -0.26704549     -0.61773336     -0.43254156
       8 H        2.01906721     -1.00977336      0.38849325
       9 H        2.85080022      1.37788378     -0.70218695
      10 H        1.61055541      2.98853186      0.77885376
      11 H        0.10007627      2.90612842      1.27543833
      12 H       -1.35548335      1.04323500      0.12809876

 STANDARD DEVIATION ON ENERGY   (KCAL)       0.00000003699    10
 STANDARD DEVIATION ON GRADIENT (KCAL/A,RD,RD)  0.00001265 0.00002233 0.00001931

 AM1 RHF SINGLET GNORM=0.05 T=AUTO TRUSTE GRAD GEO-OK    11
 Distorted Benzene
 GNORM

     GEOMETRY OPTIMIZED : ENERGY MINIMIZED    12
     SCF FIELD WAS ACHIEVED    13

                              AM1 CALCULATION    14
                                                            VERSION 10.0.1

                                                       Aug-31-2011
 
          FINAL HEAT OF FORMATION   =        22.022286 kcal
                                    =        92.163265 kJ
          ELECTRONIC ENERGY         =     -3253.371822 eV
          CORE-CORE REPULSION       =      2403.035502 eV
          TOTAL ENERGY              =      -850.336320 eV
          GRADIENT NORM             =         0.110345 
          RMS GRADIENT NORM         =         0.020146 
          UNSTABLE MODE(S)          =         0 ( ESTIMATE  )
          IONIZATION POTENTIAL      =         9.652544 eV
          HOMO-LUMO GAP             =        10.207126 eV
          MOLECULAR WEIGHT          =        78.113400 
          MOLECULAR POINT GROUP     = D6h     0.100000
          NO. OF FILLED LEVELS      =        15 (OCC = 2)
          TOTAL NUMBER OF ORBITALS  =        30
          SCF CALCULATIONS          =        26
          COMPUTATION TIME          =         0.25     SECONDS

       FINAL GEOMETRY AND DERIVATIVES    15
   PARAMETER    ATOM     TYPE            VALUE       GRADIENT
      1          2 C     BOND            1.395028     0.013427  kcal/angstrom
      2          3 C     BOND            1.395067     0.024552  kcal/angstrom
      3          3 C     ANGLE         120.000213    -0.015120  kcal/radian  
      4          4 C     BOND            1.395020    -0.017856  kcal/angstrom
      5          4 C     ANGLE         120.000241    -0.037976  kcal/radian  
      6          4 C     DIHEDRAL       -0.006540    -0.012720  kcal/radian  
      7          5 C     BOND            1.395082     0.045714  kcal/angstrom
      8          5 C     ANGLE         119.998278    -0.048351  kcal/radian  
      9          5 C     DIHEDRAL        0.001454    -0.016369  kcal/radian  
     10          6 C     BOND            1.395027     0.007002  kcal/angstrom
     11          6 C     ANGLE         120.001057    -0.018317  kcal/radian  
     12          6 C     DIHEDRAL        0.000382    -0.018189  kcal/radian  
     13          7 H     BOND            1.099676     0.021392  kcal/angstrom
     14          7 H     ANGLE         119.998309    -0.003781  kcal/radian  
     15          7 H     DIHEDRAL      180.004635     0.000475  kcal/radian  
     16          8 H     BOND            1.099643    -0.003342  kcal/angstrom
     17          8 H     ANGLE         119.999025     0.000026  kcal/radian  
     18          8 H     DIHEDRAL     -180.008087    -0.004139  kcal/radian  
     19          9 H     BOND            1.099652     0.003205  kcal/angstrom
     20          9 H     ANGLE         120.001668     0.001970  kcal/radian  
     21          9 H     DIHEDRAL      179.989239    -0.007975  kcal/radian  
     22         10 H     BOND            1.099696     0.041440  kcal/angstrom
     23         10 H     ANGLE         119.999758     0.000647  kcal/radian  
     24         10 H     DIHEDRAL     -179.996667     0.003270  kcal/radian  
     25         11 H     BOND            1.099636    -0.009138  kcal/angstrom
     26         11 H     ANGLE         119.998960    -0.004269  kcal/radian  
     27         11 H     DIHEDRAL     -180.006599    -0.006776  kcal/radian  
     28         12 H     BOND            1.099604    -0.036664  kcal/angstrom
     29         12 H     ANGLE         120.000057    -0.000174  kcal/radian  
     30         12 H     DIHEDRAL      179.987363    -0.005666  kcal/radian  
 
    ATOM    CHEMICAL   BOND LENGTH    BOND ANGLE    TWIST ANGLE    16
   NUMBER   SYMBOL     (ANGSTROMS)     (DEGREES)     (DEGREES)
    (I)                   NA:I          NB:NA:I      NC:NB:NA:I     NA    NB    NC
      1     C 
      2     C          1.39503 *                                     1
      3     C          1.39507 *      120.00021 *                    2     1
      4     C          1.39502 *      120.00024 *    -0.00654 *      3     2     1
      5     C          1.39508 *      119.99828 *     0.00145 *      4     3     2
      6     C          1.39503 *      120.00106 *     0.00038 *      5     4     3
      7     H          1.09968 *      119.99831 *   180.00463 *      1     2     3
      8     H          1.09964 *      119.99902 *  -180.00809 *      2     3     4
      9     H          1.09965 *      120.00167 *   179.98924 *      3     4     5
     10     H          1.09970 *      119.99976 *  -179.99667 *      4     5     6
     11     H          1.09964 *      119.99896 *  -180.00660 *      5     6     1
     12     H          1.09960 *      120.00006 *   179.98736 *      6     1     2

   MOLECULAR POINT GROUP            SYMMETRY CRITERIA
            D6h                         0.10000000    17

          RHF EIGENVALUES    18
    -39.14667    -31.36848    -31.36803    -23.06043    -23.06026    -17.85605
    -16.12313    -15.40009    -14.16086    -14.16065    -13.38085    -11.88763
    -11.88750     -9.65276     -9.65254      0.55458      0.55472      2.97772
      4.03635      4.03654      4.04726      4.19233      4.59843      4.59857
      5.12317      5.12327      5.61157      5.61163      5.72914      6.13270

          NET ATOMIC CHARGES AND DIPOLE CONTRIBUTIONS    19
      ATOM            CHARGE        ATOM ELECTRON DENSITY
       1 C           -0.1301          4.1301
       2 C           -0.1301          4.1301
       3 C           -0.1301          4.1301
       4 C           -0.1301          4.1301
       5 C           -0.1301          4.1301
       6 C           -0.1301          4.1301
       7 H            0.1301          0.8699
       8 H            0.1301          0.8699
       9 H            0.1301          0.8699
      10 H            0.1301          0.8699
      11 H            0.1301          0.8699
      12 H            0.1301          0.8699

 DIPOLE (DEBYE)   X         Y         Z       TOTAL
 POINT-CHG.     0.000     0.000     0.000     0.000
 HYBRID         0.000     0.000     0.000     0.000
 SUM            0.000     0.000     0.000     0.000


          CARTESIAN COORDINATES    20
      ATOM            X               Y               Z
       1 C        0.00000000      0.00000000      0.00000000
       2 C        1.39502833      0.00000000      0.00000000
       3 C        2.09256627      1.20816077      0.00000000
       4 C        1.39506581      2.41628914     -0.00013789
       5 C       -0.00001584      2.41625828     -0.00024513
       6 C       -0.69752497      1.20812680     -0.00020642
       7 H       -0.54981007     -0.95236388      0.00007704
       8 H        1.94486259     -0.95231161     -0.00002571
       9 H        3.19221826      1.20812002     -0.00009433
      10 H        1.94488876      3.36866836     -0.00011301
      11 H       -0.54985468      3.36855913     -0.00051752
      12 H       -1.79712908      1.20811925     -0.00041645


          ATOMIC ORBITAL ELECTRON POPULATIONS    21
      1.21858      0.93887      0.97267      1.00000      1.21858      0.93887
      0.97266      1.00000      1.21858      0.98956      0.92198      1.00000
      1.21859      0.93887      0.97266      1.00000      1.21859      0.93887
      0.97266      1.00000      1.21857      0.98956      0.92198      1.00001
      0.86988      0.86988      0.86988      0.86987      0.86989      0.86989
 
     ELAPSED WALL CLOCK TIME :      0.29 SECONDS    22
     FULL COMPUTATION TIME :      0.27 SECONDS    23
	

1

The banner indicates which Hamiltonian (here AM1) was used to obtain the results.

2

As in the archive file, this line gives information about which version of AMPAC (in this case 10.0) was used in this calculation. This data must be referenced when publishing results.

3

The keywords that AMPAC recognized from the input file are printed here and short summaries of their functions are provided. If an expected keyword is not present in this group, check the input file for spelling or omission.

4

The keyword, title, and comment lines are echoed to the output file to help the user identify the calculation.

5

The internal coordinates of the initial geometry (whether provided to the program as internals or Cartesians) are listed. Only those geometric parameters with asterisks (*) beside them will be optimized.

6

The symmetry of the input geometry and the threshold used in determining symmetry is output here. MPGCRT can be used to adjust this threshold.

7

This short section defines the calculation that AMPAC expects to perform. In this case a singlet spin state is assumed (default if no spin multiplicity keywords are used). Open shell calculations (UHF) will show the electrons divided between alpha and beta electron spin states.

8

References to the parameters for the particular Hamiltonian chosen are listed. These citations should be used in papers. A complete bibliography may be found in Chapter 17, References.

9

The Cartesian coordinates of the initial geometry (again whether provided to the program as internals or Cartesians) are listed. This output may be suppressed by use of the NOXYZ keyword.

10

A summary of the geometry optimization methods and criteria is presented in this section. More information, including results for each step, may be obtained by using the PRINT=n keyword.

11

Again, the keyword line, title, and comment lines are echoed to the output file.

12

This message is one of the several that AMPAC can provide to inform the user that the geometry has been properly optimized (see the section called “Geometry Optimization” for a list and description of the possible messages). Always check this line for possible failure of the geometry optimization or SCF procedure.

13

This message informs the user that SCF convergence was attained at the geometry that the optimization halted on. The results following are for the final wavefunction and geometry.

14

This summary section is almost an exact copy of that found in the archive file. See above for an explanation of its components.

15

The gradient components that are used to compute the gnorm are listed here for each optimizable parameter. This report is a result of using the keyword GRAD. The gnorm should have a low value as should each component. In the event that a geometry optimization is not converging, an examination of these components may suggest a method of redefining the geometry so that a particularly troublesome component with a high gradient value is eliminated.

16

The internal coordinates of the fully optimized geometry are printed here. Again, only those components noted with an asterisk have been optimized.

17

The symmetry of the optimized geometry and the threshold used in determining symmetry is output here. MPGCRT can be used to adjust this threshold.

18

The energy values (in eV) of the final molecular orbitals (both occupied and virtual) are listed here. In benzene, there are 15 occupied MOs, with the highest being a degenerate pair corresponding to part of the π bonding picture. Generally, occupied MOs have energies < 0.0 eV and virtuals have energies > 0.0 eV.

19

The partial charges on each atom are tabulated. This quantity is obtained by subtracting the sum of the number of core electrons and the valence electrons present on that atom as predicted by AMPAC from the atomic number (number of protons). These figures are used to compute the net dipole moment of the species.

20

The Cartesian coordinates of the final geometry are printed. This output may be suppressed by use of the NOXYZ keyword.

21

The valence orbital electron populations (the diagonal of the final density matrix) are listed for reference.

22

The wall clock time expresses the total time taken by the calculation from start ot finish as experienced by the user (or a clock on the wall).

23

The full computation time for the calculation is a measure of the time spent by the CPU in performing this calculation. It is similar to, but not the same as, the wall clock time.